Vegan-friendly
Lacto
Ovo
American
Organic
Fast food
Take-out

Storefront near Tompkins Square Park offering veggie burgers, sloppy joe, rice bowls, wraps, and desserts. A few seats. Est. summer 2015. Relocated from 430 E 9th St. No reservations; walk ins only. Open Mon-Wed 5:00pm-11:30pm, Thu-Sat 5:00pm-2:00am, Sat-Sun 11:00am-2:30pm, Sun 5:00pm-11:30pm.


Venue map for Superiority Burger
© OpenStreetMap contributors

45 Reviews

First Review by ManhattanTransfer

monandeclan

Points +171

Vegan
07 Dec 2024

Just meh.

Hubby and I are visiting NYC for the holidays and stopped here for lunch on a Friday afternoon, right as they opened. We were seated promptly, the waitress explained the specials and fetched our drinks. The menu is quite small. We ordered the vegan version of the Superiority burger and the vegan chili cheese dog that was on special. The burger came with nice thick fries and the chili cheese dog came with chips and a small side of macaroni salad.

Overall the food was mediocre. The burger and the hot dog were both very mushy and the dog did not taste at all like a hot dog. It filled the void but that was it.

The service was attentive and friendly.

It was also not inexpensive at $80 for a burger, hotdog, one beer and one glass of wine, including tax and service. However this is NYC.

Pros: Great service., good fries

Cons: mushy veggie burger

NoCheesePlease!

Points +36

Vegan
19 Nov 2024

Tasty but too pricey

Tasty but just paid 40 bucks for 2x sandwiches..

Pros: Burger , Tvf

Monila

Points +643

Vegan
20 Oct 2024

Very good food! Not all vegan though

Very good food but not all vegan so have to make sure with staff. The service was a little slow but everyone was very nice. I sat at the bar. A little pricey but it’s to be expected.

Pros: Tasty and unique vegan options, Good dessert

Cons: Not all vegan

GrayHorwitz

Points +2008

Vegan
10 Jul 2024

Original tastes, local ingredients, but $$$

The mochi cake was quite nice, as were the pickled sweet potatoes, but I just have a hard time justifying the portion sizes with the cost. Especially for the signature namesake dish. Fine dining in a diner style establishment.

Also so close to all vegan!

Updated from previous review on 2024-07-10

Jamchiller

10 Jul 2024

hugemittons

Points +1610

Vegan
29 Jun 2024

Good but expensive

Was it delicious? Absolutely. Worth $20? Probably not.

AfterSeeingOkjaTwice

Points +535

Vegan
07 Jun 2024

Nice dinner

The burger was really good; softer than other vegan burgers and very nice. I was disappointed by the yuba but I liked the bread. Pricey, but a great vibe and setting there!

nmp4eva

Points +38

Vegan
02 May 2024

Pricey

Why is this food so expensive? I feel like I can make something at home that is cheaper and tastes better. Which is what I will do next time. 

redflowerlizzie

Points +68

Vegan
23 Mar 2024

love the ambiance, great vegan options

the yuba sandwich is STUNNING. highly recommended. black sesame ice cream was great too. next time i go i definitely want to try some of the other desserts (cake slices, etc). has good cocktail menu as well!

veganlabor

Points +37

Vegan
10 Mar 2024

lxs mejores

the best people making the best food. the specials are always where its at.

Updated from previous review on 2024-03-10

jakertz

Points +103

Vegan
05 Nov 2023

It was good, not great

I came here on a recommendation from a bike tour guide. It was just okay. The sloppy Dave (tofu sloppy Joe) was very salty. I also had the burned broccoli salad, it was good but had a taste I didn’t care for. I don’t think I’d go back. It was too pricey for the meh tasting food. The broccoli and sloppy Dave were almost $30. Glad it was busy but it’s not the quality I’m used to for a vegetarian/vegan spot.

Pros: All vegetarian, can be made vegan.

Cons: Far too salty, Expensive

madoublethew

Points +308

Vegan
21 Oct 2023

Amazing

This place is just so good, and the vibe is so fun. There were dishes that I would happily eat every day. The cornbread that comes with the spicy lentils was mind-blowing - the first made me sad to think that it was going to be gone soon. The Sloppy Dave was great, and the peanut butter pie felt like eating a cloud. I didn’t love the burnt broccoli salad, if I’m honest, but the candied cashews that came with it were delish, so it wasn’t all bad.

mlcastle

Points +91

Vegetarian
13 Sep 2023

so so good but pricey

The new Superiority Burger space is fun and the expanded menu is as tasty as ever. Especially don't sleep on the yuba sandwich! Cocktails and a full bar are now available too if that's your thing.

Really the only downside is to make a meal of it you kind of need to order a sandwich and a side and it's hard to do that for less than $40, which really kind of pushes it out of the elevated fast food price bracket they pretend to be playing in.

Updated from previous review on 2023-09-13

JulieFrancine

Points +102

Vegan
17 Jul 2023

Good!

Just visited them in their new location. The new location used to be a popular Ukrainian/Polish restaurant so it was fun to be back in the space… quite the same as when it was Odessa. I applaud anyone who opens a restaurant, especially a vegetarian restaurant… BUT… i just think of you are going to be a “burger joint” then the burgers should “kill” and not murmur…

Updated from previous review on 2018-09-06

Pros: Good to take out to eat in nearby Tompkins Square

Cons: Sometimes too crowded! , Very small indoor seating

TheTofuTyrant

Points +2135

Vegan
13 Apr 2023

Delicious!!

I came here with some vegetarian friends and it was amazing!!

Pros: all vegetarian

kk1018

Points +211

Vegan
01 Dec 2021

Tasty and unique veggie burgers

Great veggie burgers that aren’t just impossible/beyond meat. I love this place. The burgers are on the smaller side FYI so you might want to get more than 1 or get a side too.

Pros: All vegan

csailor

Points +877

Vegan
10 Aug 2021

Very Good

Very tasty food and not overly expensive. I love the fact that everything is super fresh as well and rotates with seasonal veg. Would love to see a menu online as well as an option to order ahead too because the line *can* get very long.

Updated from previous review on 2021-05-02

drquayle

Points +738

Vegan
02 Jul 2021

Not my favorite

This place wasn’t my favorite, although I do love supporting vegetarian restaurants. I personally think there are better options out there.

sugz

Points +436

Vegan
15 Oct 2020

I don’t have enough good things to say about this place!

You gotta come here, the hype is real! These burgers are to die for and the ice ream!!! Omfg. They have seasonal soups and creative combos, the iced cream flavors change all the time, their salads are wonderful.

Pros: Everything is to die for , Seasonal flavors, Always something new

a7c

Points +513

Vegan
29 Aug 2020

Great burgers

Great burgers but very tiny restaurant. Probably best to get to-go.

BarbaraG.Baz

Points +1715

Vegan
01 Aug 2020

Good burgers

Good burgers, very different but small portions. Small space. God flavours.

talevis

Points +127

Vegan
11 Feb 2020

Favorite spot in East Village

Honestly, this place is extremely underrated. It has the most unique and delicious vegan food I've had. Plus, the focaccia is to die for!

mountainRain

Points +106

Vegan
26 Oct 2019

Tiny

This place is tiny. Although there are 3 to 4 seats, they’re mainly for individuals. It feels cramped. The burgers are decent, on the smaller size portion, but not amazingly different from other places. If you happen to be in the area, it’s worth a visit. Otherwise, it’s very inconvenient and probably not worth a special trip.

Pros: Vegan

Cons: Small, cramped

Poundie

Points +15533

Vegan
18 Oct 2019

Tiny place that hits the spot

A small burger place with a hip atmosphere with a small menu of vegetarian burgers (though everything can be made vegan). The place is very cramped; though there is seating you should plan on take-out (there is a park nearby). I confess that I prefer the fast food in the Vegan Court which is nearby on St. Marks place; still, the food here is tasty and good for a quick bite.

Pros: Filling, tasty, Hip atmosphere

Cons: Very cramped, Not super healthy

RubyL

Points +201

Vegan
02 Oct 2019

AMAZING burger

Believe the hype on this one, I really thought the burger was delicious. It's not trying to be meat-like and its not your typical grainy veg based burger either. It has a unique texture and the flavour is amazing. Hard to describe, you should try the burger for yourself! I loved it. The sides were less memorable (still tasty though) so overall a great takeaway spot in this 'hip' area.

IrisCredo

Points +74

Vegan
07 Jul 2019

Great flavors

Great spot for take out (difficult to dine in when it's super busy). Tasty burgers and wraps.

RebeccaBlowes

Points +367

Vegan
02 May 2019

Accidentally vegan, deliberately delicious

Dinky tasty burgers available as vegetarian or vegan at this hole in the wall style burger joint. Definitely worth a special trip at least once while in NYC.

Pros: Tasty vegan options

veganskinhead

Points +267

Vegan
26 Nov 2018

So hip, so good.

A place that is too hip for its own good, but that sums up the changing Lower East Side. Good burgers, though. Eat in Tompkins Square Park as you'll be lucky to find a space inside.




This page has been viewed 12670 times.