Lacto
Ovo
American
Mediterranean
Beer/Wine
Take-out
Honey
Breakfast
Non-veg
Serves meat, vegan options available. Diner and restaurant with vegan choices. Separate plant-based menu includes lentil soup, Impossible burger, quinoa salad, vegetable hummus sandwich, vegan egg breakfast plate, meatball sandwich, souvlaki and more. Open Mon-Thu 7:00am-12:00am, Fri-Sat 7:00am-1:00am, Sun 7:00am-12:00am.
© OpenStreetMap contributors
-
205 W 57th St, New York City, New York, USA, 10019
-
Loading...
-
- Outdoor seating
- Accepts credit cards
-
-
Last update on 15 Oct 2023 by MarlaWilks
Update business info -
Are you the owner?
Claim this business -
Added by PlayerOne on 15 Jun 2023
-
-
10 Reviews
First Review by PlayerOne
EceBaykut
Points +34
Many options, good flavors - Edit
They had more vegan options than a lot of NYC restaurants. The lentil soup was very good, although I wasn’t sure if the toast it came with had butter or margarine on it. The impossible burger was standard. The vegan chocolate cake was VERY good.
Read moreUpdated from previous review on 2024-10-26
Guest
DionneWhite
Points +46
Great lunch - Edit
Great plant based menu options which was great to see in NYC
Read morePros: Choices, Good, Service
Guest
MeaganKiely
Points +769
Expensive spinach - Edit
Farmers salad was okay but mostly just spinach and oil - few figs and hazelnuts. Cost me $40 odd AUD 😳 was only worth half that.
Read moreveganqueenofqueensnyc
Highway robbery! I consider Carnegie Diner to be a tourist trap, though admittedly, prices here in NYC in general are over the top.
Read moreGuest
Poundie
Points +15243
I appreciate the effort! - Edit
This dinner is kitty-corner from Carnegie Hall. The food is not inexpensive (pricier than what one might expect from a diner), but the portions are huge. I had a vegan burger and lentil soup; both were pretty good. This diner has a whole page devoted to plant-based foods--but it is not quite vegan. For instance, the fries were cooked in the same oil as the meat; the salad had honey vinegar dressing; I was served non-vegan cole slaw with my vegan burger; none of the desserts are vegan; etc. Fortunately, I alerted the friendly servers that I wanted vegan food, and they were careful to accommodate me (for instance, swapping the fries for veggies; swapping the salad dressing, etc.). But be forewarned: you should not automatically expect that everything listed on the plant-based page of the menu is vegan unless you double- or triple-check.
Read morePros: Huge portions, pretty good tasting food., near Carnegie Hall
Cons: Pricey for a diner, the plant-based listings are not all vegan
Guest
SelenaClauson
Points +86
Great diner with lots of vegan options - Edit
An entire page of vegan options from breakfast to dinner!
Read morePros: Delicious , Great atmosphere
Cons: All “meat” dishes used impossible meat, Expensive
Guest
Vegan Vagabond
Points +3944
A for effort - Edit
First, I really appreciate this diner having a separate plant-based menu. I stopped in for breakfast and got the egg breakfast. There’s a picture of this breakfast as the main picture on HappyCow and they have changed the dish. It’s a little odd, but it is an omelette on a multigrain roll (omelette sandwich?), and then you get french fries instead of hashbrowns, along with a salad. Once I got past that, it was pretty good. When I return, I would ask for toast instead of the multigrain roll and ask for hashbrowns instead of french fries. I’d also prefer fruit over the salad.
Read moreThe service was great, the people were friendly, and I would go back again.
Guest
MarlaWilks
Points +117
Plant menu and huge portions - Edit
Good service, great food, huge portions. We split a vegan breakfast sandwich and our kids split an order of non- vegan pancakes and we had food leftover.
Read moreGuest
ajvzla
Points +152
Vegan menu and good food! - Edit
Big portion, tasty and a variety of vegan option. Pricey.
Read moreGuest
vagovegano
Points +5309
Full plant-based menu… - Edit
Awesome job with a full plant-based menu at this popular diner. I ordered the omelette plate which was fair, nothing spectacular. The menu has all the main ingredients for a vegan menu including vegan egg, vegan cheese, Impossible patty, etc. I’ll have to try some of their other offerings before I would give a higher rating.
Read morePros: Full plant-based menu
Cons: Food just ok
Guest
PlayerOne
Points +220
Great Plant-based options! - Edit
Great experience with a separate plant-based menu that included breakfast omelette, sandwiches, and more. Lunch and dinner also featured in the menu. The coffee was fantastic for a diner!
Read morePros: Separate plant-based menu, Tons of options, Friendly staff
jifrah
Honey lime vinaigrette on the egg breakfast?
Read moreGuest
For Members
Why was my review removed? Guidelines for writing a review View our privacy policyFor Business Owners
Claim this business See inaccurate information? Submit an update here Link to this page from your site See an unfair review? View full terms & conditionsThis page has been viewed 4832 times.